Uncommonly Grounded
Fresh from playing gay in Showtime’s Common Ground, teen heartthrob Jonathan Taylor Thomas comfortably confronts rumors about his own sexuality.
By Dennis Hensley. Photographed by Greg Henry for The Advocate.
For many readers of The Advocate, seeing Jonathan Taylor Thomas on the cover is not an entirely foreign concept. In the spring of 1998, the Internet was suddenly rife with rumors that the then-16-year-old heartthrob, who was winding up his eighth and last year playing Tim Allen’s sarcastic son Randy Taylor on the venerable sitcom Home Improvement, was gay and coming out in the pages of this very magazine. Like many such fables that somehow gain momentum—the Keanu Reeves-David Geffen marriage hoax comes to mind—the story’s genesis was difficult to trace, but it spooked the young star’s representatives enough to threaten The Advocate and other gay publications with legal action. They needn’t have bothered, for the supposed tell-all interview did not exist—for no other reason than the fact that Thomas is not gay.
It should be noted that the Pennsylvania-born, California-bred Thomas himself is not spooked by the word gay. Indeed, he embraces a major gay role in the new Showtime movie Common Ground, an If These Walls Could Talk-style trio of vignettes about what it’s like to be homosexual in small-town America in the ‘50s, ‘70s, and now. In the ‘70s-set portion, written by Tony-award-winning gay playwright Terrence McNally (Love! Valour! Compassion!), Thomas dives into the role of Toby Anderson, a high school swimming star, who, after enduring the homophobic and violent taunts of his team members, opens up to his favorite teacher, Mr. Roberts (Jeffrey’s Steven Weber), who he senses is also gay. Unfortunately for Toby, Mr. Roberts prefers to remain closeted.
After Toby’s fumbled attempt to prove his manliness with a female hooker, the piece builds to a harrowing locker-room scene in which our golden boy is gay-bashed and then forced to service one of his teammates while the rest do nothing to stop it. Not exactly the kind of plot points one would find in an episode of Home Improvement, not even a very special one.
Director Nickolas, who cast Thomas as a bisexual hustler in the indie film Speedway Junky, applauds the actor’s willingness to turn his teen idol image—born from his Improvement days as well as roles in films such as Tom and Huck and Wild America—on its head. “I think what he’s trying to do is show that he’s capable of a lot more things than people think he is,” proclaims Perry. For the edgy Speedway, executive-produced by Gus Van Sant and due out in the spring. Thomas was required to give a three-page speech on how to be an effective hustler. “I had the inspiration of doing the entire scene in one shot with no cuts,” Perry recalls. “My favorite moment was that look on Jonathan’s face when I told him what I wanted to do. But he just did it and completely pulled it off.”
“Jonathan was up for everything,” echoes Common Ground’s out director, Donna Deitch. “A great deal was demanded of him, and he was completely committed. He even went for the Speedo.”
And, rumour mill be damned, Thomas went for the interview with The Advocate. Clad in jeans, a grey sweater, and a baseball cap, the straight-A high school student—who, since his parents’ divorce when he was 8, has been raised with his brother, Joel, by their mom, Claudine—discussed his take on gossip and gays. Through it all he was long on boyish charm but also revealed himself to be more measured and articulate than his Teen Beat image would suggest.
Starring in Common Ground was a pretty bold move for a young actor, especially considering those rumors—which we’ll get to. What about the project appealed to you?
It was really well-written by Terrence McNally, and I liked the character. He’s very driven, very smart, and he just wants to be accepted. But I liked that he doesn’t want to let other people’s hatred and insecurities prevent him from being the best he can be.
You also play a bisexual hustler in the upcoming movie Speedway Junky. I believe your first line is, “So did you get fucked in the ass today?”
[Laughs] Right, yeah. Nice character.
In taking these roles, were you trying to shake your wholesome image?
I thought, If I am going to grow as an actor, I need to challenge myself. I didn’t do these pieces to change my image. I did them for me. I had an attachment to these characters.
What about your agents—did they say, “It’s great that you want to stretch, Jonathan, but could you maybe squeeze a Disney movie in too?”
They were completely cool. They understand that I’m not trying to tap out and spend the rest of my years on a beach in Bali.
Your mom is also your manager. Was she cool too?
Completely. I watched Speedway Junky sitting right next to her, where every third word out of my mouth was a cussword. It was a little awkward, but she knows who I am.
Do you think your Speedway character made good money as a hustler?
I think he probably did pretty well [laughs]. That’s what I like about acting: You get to live out these fantasies, and then you go home at night to your normal life, go back to just being Jon.
Speaking of people’s fantasies, what’s your take on the rumors that you had told The Advocate that you were gay?
The whole thing started on this Web site called CyberSleaze, which should probably tell you something. My agent called me and said, “There’s this stuff going around.” I got phone calls from my friends saying, “What are you going to do about this?” It was just a blatant lie put on the Internet, and then it was just like a feeding frenzy. And I’m sure it was validated by my recent roles.
Did it make you angry?
No. I was completely fine with it—until my grandmother, who is 95 years old, happened to hear people talking about it on a radio station in Pennsylvania. She was a little upset. What startled me was how willingly people accepted it.
I don’t think you’ve really made it in Hollywood until people think you’re gay.
[Laughs] Exactly.
Did you ever log on to see what the actual story was?
No, I really didn’t want to deal with it, and at the time I was working on a Disney film, I’ll Be Home for Christmas.
Or as they like to call it on CyberSleaze…
…I’ll Be Homo for Christmas. But to be honest, I didn’t get pissed off. It wasn’t like, “I’ve got to go on every program and dispel this awful thing.”
I think the idea that an actor your age is sitting here talking to The Advocate reflects how attitudes about homosexuality are changing. Do you sense your generation is more enlightened than previous ones?
Yeah. I think people overall are becoming more accepting, partly because it is more prevalent in the media. Part of what Common Ground does really well is express the humanity of these people. It’s difficult to have any animosity if you recognize that on so many levels they’re exactly the same as you.
What do you think would happen professionally if a successful young actor were to come out?
I don’t know, but I would hope that, like anyone else, he would be measured by their merit and their talent.
Do you remember your first exposure to a gay person?
Not really. I’ve been working in Hollywood since I was 8, so it was never a big deal. Over the years I’ve worked with so many smart, funny, talented gay people, and I just don’t think about it. They’re my friends.
You seem remarkably self-possessed for someone your age. Where do you think that comes from?
I don’t know. My mom always made sure I got the things I needed in life. I think in the end it does all come down to parenting.
When you’re not studying or thinking about the next important role, what might you be doing?
Fly-fishing in the morning in Montana or watching a football game.
My God, you are straight. Do you have a girlfriend?
Not at the moment.
Are there any movie stars who make your heart beat fast?
Cameron Diaz. I met her really briefly. She pinched my cheeks, and then she told me that I reminded her of her brother. That just crushed me.
You have a tremendous legion of pining fans yourself. After all, you were the voice of Young Simba in The Lion King. Children—and gays—must worship you.
I get a kick out of it when people enjoy that movie, but my voice has changed. I’m no longer Young Simba. That’s very clear.
You’re a senior in high school now. Do you wreak havoc on the underclassmen?
No. You know what, I’m kind of more sympathetic toward them because I remember when I was a freshman, and, you know, I remember what it was like. You know, pairing up with these big seniors and knowing, My God, they’re just gigantic, and I’m never going to be like that, and then sure enough four years go by like that. So I kind of empathize with the position they’re in. So I’m nice to them. I like the underclassmen.
In Common Ground you got to do a ’70s thing without sporting too many bad clothes or hair.
Which was good. When I first read ’70s, I was thinking bell bottoms, Afros, all kinds of wild things. When I got up there and met with the wardrobe department, I was quite pleased. I was like, OK, some cool sneakers, a little bit of flare on the pants. Not too bad. A little boot cut. I can live with that.
But you did have to wear a Speedo. That’s a little brave.
Yeah, well, that wasn’t something I was looking forward to. And, of course, it was relatively minimal, which I’m glad…
The suit itself is minimal?
No! How much you see is minimal. The suit itself is minimal as well, but that’s the nature of the Speedo.
You play a bit of an overachiever. Can you relate to him?
I think so. That’s what I liked about him. It comes back to drive, ambition. This kid wants to be something. And he doesn’t want to let other people’s hostilities and hatred and insecurities prevent him from being the best he can be and living out his life as he wants to live it. Someone who didn’t have as strong a will or maybe wasn’t as confident as Toby is might have backed down [and] not come out.
What was it like doing the scene in the locker room when the other boys sort of terrorize Toby for being gay?
It was a hard scene to do for a number of different reasons. Not only were we filming late, it had been a long day. The physicality of the scene, and we were working with five actors, including myself. And it’s a stunt scene, throwing punches, and whatnot. And none of us are stuntmen. So there’s an added pressure when you’re dealing with throwing punches and you don’t want to get hit, you don’t want to get hurt. You want to make the scene look as realistic as possible. And then, it was just intense. The way it’s shot as well… It’s sort of continuous, where there’s—I get kind of pulled back into the shower area and the camera keeps on swishing back and forth.
The implication is that Toby is raped.
It’s up to the viewer to decide—what is their own personal torture? And they can kind of associate that with what Toby must be going through. What would be the nightmare for them? And that’s what I kind of liked about it. We didn’t have to blatantly show exactly what was going on. It lets the viewer be smart, use their imagination. And I think that’s oftentimes a lot more powerful in filmmaking, when you suggest things as opposed to showing them. Because when you show something, there’s only one interpretation: what is on the screen. You allude to something, and it leaves the viewer to kind of go, Wow. And they’re forced to think about it and process it and imagine what could be happening there. And certainly you know it’s torture, it’s horrible, and this kid is being demeaned sexually, mentally—it’s horrifying. But that’s the reality and the trauma and the torture of what this kid had to endure.
What did you learn about yourself through this experience in Common Ground?
What it’s like to feel isolated and alone and having no one to turn to. And I think in filming that scene in the bathroom, I started to get it. I think I can never fully comprehend it. But I think that I started to get a clearer picture of what it may be like to be a young kid struggling with your sexuality and not being able to go there. And it doesn’t even have to be an issue of sexuality. It could be anyone who’s facing prejudice and hatred and looking at society and thinking that everyone around you is against you. I think that’s a really horrifying picture. Where you literally have no one to turn to. The one thing about Toby is that the one person he turns to initially is his teacher, and even he denies him. And so the one person that he thinks is like him and he can associate with and can really go to and say, “This is who I am, I need you right now,” slams the door in his face initially. And so that is a very dark and cold place to be.
Speaking of dark places, you played Greg Brady’s son in an early-’90s revival of The Brady Bunch. What’s your definitive Brady memory?
Florence Henderson. She’s cool. She went to a Super Bowl and came back and gave me a commemorative ball from that Super Bowl, and I thought that was incredibly nice of her to be there. Out of all people…
So that rumor about Florence Henderson balling you…
[Laughs] That’s exactly how these things start.
